| | | | |
| 1952 | Joe Heap*** | Football | 1st | B |
| 1953 | Joe Heap*** | Football | 1st | B |
| 1954 | Joe Heap*** | Football | 1st | HB |
| 1954 | Dan Shannon | Football | 2nd | TE |
| 1955 | Dan Schaefer | Football | 1st | B |
| 1958 | Bob Wetoska | Football | 1st | E |
| 1959 | Ken Adamson | Football | 3rd | G |
| 1963 | Bob Lehman | Football | 1st | G |
| 1963 | Tom Talaga | Football | HM | SE |
| 1966 | Jim Lynch | Football | 1st | LB |
| 1966 | Tom Regner | Football | 1st | OG |
| 1967 | Bob Arnzen*** | Men's Basketball | 1st | F |
| 1967 | Jim Smithberger | Football | 1st | DB |
| 1968 | Bob Arnzen*** | Men's Basketball | 1st | F |
| 1968 | George Kunz | Football | 1st | OT |
| 1969 | Bob Arnzen*** | Men's Basketball | 1st | F |
| 1969 | Jim Reilly | Football | 1st | OT |
| 1970 | Larry DiNardo | Football | 1st | OG |
| 1970 | Tom Gatewood** | Football | 1st | SE |
| 1970 | Joe Theismann+ | Football | 1st | QB |
| 1971 | Tom Gatewood** | Football | 1st | OE |
| 1971 | Greg Marx** | Football | 1st | DT |
| 1972 | Dave Casper**+ | Football | 2nd | OT |
| 1972 | Michael Creaney | Football | 1st | TE |
| 1972 | Greg Marx** | Football | 1st | OT |
| 1972 | Gary Novak** | Men's Basketball | 2nd | C/F |
| 1973 | Dave Casper**+ | Football | 1st | TE |
| 1973 | Gary Potempa | Football | 1st | LB |
| 1973 | Robert Thomas+ | Football | 1st | K |
| 1974 | Mark Brenneman | Football | 2nd | C |
| 1974 | Reggie Barnett | Football | 1st | DB |
| 1974 | Pete Demmerle | Football | 1st | SE |
| 1974 | Gary Novak** | Men's Basketball | 2nd | F |
| 1977 | Tim Pollock | Baseball | 1st | C |
| 1977 | Joe Restic** | Football | 1st | S |
| 1977 | Dave Vinson | Football | 1st | OG |
| 1977 | Ken MacAfee | Football | 1st | TE |
| 1978 | Joe Restic** | Football | 1st | DB |
| 1978 | Tom Gibbons*** | Football | 2nd | DB |
| 1979 | Kelly Tripucka | Men's Basketball | 1st | F |
| 1979 | Tom Gibbons*** | Football | 2nd | DB |
| 1979 | Rob Martinovich | Football | 2nd | OT |
| 1980 | David Bartish | Baseball | 1st | SS |
| 1980 | Rich Branning | Men's Basketball | 1st | G |
| 1980 | Maggie Lally** | Women's Basketball | 2nd | G |
| 1980 | Bob Burger+ | Football | 1st | OG |
| 1980 | Tom Gibbons*** | Football | 1st | DB |
| 1981 | Margaret Lally** | Women's Basketball | 2nd | G |
| 1981 | Shari Matvey | Women's Basketball | 2nd | C |
| 1981 | Henry Valenzeula | Baseball | 3rd | 1B |
| 1981 | Rick Chryst | Baseball 3rd | SS |
| 1981 | John Krimm | Football | 1st | DB |
| 1981 | Kevin Griffith | Football | 2nd | DL |
| 1982 | John Paxson**+ | Men's Basketball | 1st | G |
| 1983 | John Paxson**+ | Men's Basketball | 1st | G |
| 1983 | Mary Beth Schueth | Women's Basketball | 2nd | F |
| 1983 | Greg Dingens*** | Football | 2nd | DL |
| 1984 | Mark Clementz | Baseball | HM | P |
| 1984 | James Dee | Baseball | 1st | 3B |
| 1984 | Greg Dingens*** | Football | 2nd | DL |
| 1985 | John Krug** | Men's At-Large (Wrestling) | 3rd | |
| 1985 | John Loughran*** | Baseball | 2nd | OF |
| 1985 | Rick Vanthournout** | Baseball | 1st | IF |
| 1985 | Greg Dingens*** | Football | 1st | DL |
| 1986 | John Krug** | Men's At-Large (Wrestling) | HM | |
| 1986 | John Loughran *** | Baseball | 1st | OF |
| 1986 | Rick Vanthournout** | Baseball | 3rd | 3B |
| 1987 | John Loughran *** | Baseball | 2nd | OF |
| 1987 | Ted Gradel | Football | 1st | K |
| 1987 | Vince Phelan | Football | 1st | P |
| 1988 | Tom Mick | Men's At-Large (Track & Field) | 3rd | |
| 1988 | Dan Peltier** | Baseball | 3rd | OF |
| 1988 | Reggie Ho | Football | 2nd | K |
| 1989 | Erik Madsen | Baseball | 3rd | P |
| 1989 | Dan Peltier** | Baseball | 2nd | OF |
| 1989 | Theresa Rice | Women's At-Large (Cross Country) | 1st | |
| 1991 | Joe Binkiewicz** | Baseball | 3rd | 1B |
| 1991 | Heidi Piper** | Women's At-Large (Fencing) | 2nd | |
| 1992 | Joe Binkiewicz** | Baseball | 1st | 1B |
| 1992 | Cory Mee | Baseball | 1st | 3B |
| 1992 | Jessica Fiebelkorn | Volleyball | 2nd | MB |
| 1992 | Heidi Piper** | Women's At-Large (Fencing) | 3rd | |
| 1992 | Tim Ruddy**# | Football | 1st | C |
| 1993 | Tim Ruddy**# | Football | 1st | C |
| 1993 | Casey McMurray | Softball | 2nd | UT |
| 1994 | Mark Zataveski | Football | 2nd | OL |
| 1994 | Andy Zurcher | Men's At-Large (Tennis) | 3rd | |
| 1995 | Joy Battersby*** | Softball | 2nd | P |
| 1995 | Chris Dean | Men's At-Large (Soccer) | 2nd | D |
| 1995 | Katie Marten*** | Softball | 3rd | DH |
| 1995 | Mike McWilliams | Men's At-Large (Track & Field) | 2nd | |
| 1996 | Joy Battersby*** | Softball | 2nd | P |
| 1996 | Wendy Crabtree | Women's At-Large (Tennis) | 3rd | |
| 1996 | Claudette deBruin | Women's At-Large (Fencing) | 2nd | |
| 1996 | Jenna Knudson | Softball | 3rd | OF |
| 1996 | Bill Lester** | Men's At-Large (Fencing) | 2nd | |
| 1996 | Katie Marten*** | Softball | 2nd | DH |
| 1996 | Meghan Murray** | Softball | 2nd | IF |
| 1996 | Jen Renola**# | Women's At-Large (Soccer) | 2nd | G |
| 1996 | Amy VanLaecke** | Women's At-Large (Soccer) | 2nd | F |
| 1997 | Joy Battersby*** | Softball | 3rd | P |
| 1997 | Dave Cashen | Men's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 2nd | D |
| 1997 | Pat Garrity**# | Men's Basketball | 1st | F |
| 1997 | Jeff Hojnacki | Men's At-Large (Track & Field) | 3rd | |
| 1997 | Bill Lester** | Men's At-Large (Fencing) | 1st | |
| 1997 | Katie Marten*** | Softball | 1st | DH |
| 1997 | Kara McMahon | Softball | 2nd | IF |
| 1997 | Meghan Murray** | Softball | 1st | IF |
| 1997 | Steve Noble** | Men's At-Large (Hockey) | 2nd | C |
| 1997 | Jen Renola**# | Women's At-Large (Soccer) | 1st | G |
| 1997 | Jason Rexing** | Men's At-Large (Track & Field) | 3rd | |
| 1997 | Amy VanLaecke** | Women's At-Large (Soccer) | 1st | F |
| 1997 | Jamie Lee | Volleyball | 2nd | OH |
| 1998 | Pat Garrity**# | Men's Basketball | 1st | F |
| 1998 | Steve Noble** | Men's At-Large (Hockey) | 1st | C |
| 1998 | Jason Rexing** | Men's At-Large (Track & Field) | 2nd | |
| 1998 | Jenny Streiffer** | Women's At-Large (Soccer) | 1st | F/M |
| 1998 | Ryan Turner | Men's At-Large (Soccer) | 3rd | F |
| 1998 | Errol Williams | Men's At-Large (Track & Field) | 1st | |
| 1999 | Michael Brown | Men's At-Large (Track & Field) | 2nd | |
| 1999 | Kerry Callahan | Women's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 2nd | A |
| 1999 | Jennifer Hall | Women's At-Large (Tennis) | 3rd | |
| 1999 | Forrest Karr | Men's At-Large (Hockey) | 2nd | G |
| 1999 | Alison Klemmer** | Women's At-Large (Track & Field) | 3rd | |
| 1999 | Phil Murphy | Men's At-Large (Soccer) | 1st | M/D |
| 1999 | Jenny Streiffer** | Women's At-Large (Soccer) | 2nd | F/M |
| 2000 | Jeff Connell | Men's At-Large (Golf) | 3rd | |
| 2000 | Steve Fiamingo | Men's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 2nd | D |
| 2000 | Raymond Fitzpatrick | Men's At-Large (Swimming) | 3rd | |
| 2000 | Andy Jurkowski | Men's At-Large (Hockey) | 3rd | LW |
| 2000 | Alison Klemmer** | Women's At-Large (Track & Field) | 2nd | |
| 2000 | Jarrah Myers***# | Softball | 3rd | C |
| 2000 | Mike Naumann** | Baseball | 3rd | P |
| 2000 | Jeff Perconte | Baseball | 1st | IF |
| 2000 | Ruth Riley**#! | Women's Basketball | 1st | C |
| 2001 | Mike Adams | Men's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 1st | D |
| 2001 | Leah Ashe | Women's At-Large (Rowing) | 2nd | |
| 2001 | Dan Carlson | Men's At-Large (Hockey) | 3rd | LW |
| 2001 | Meotis Erikson | Women's At-Large (Soccer) | 3rd | F |
| 2001 | Jarrah Myers***# | Softball | 1st | C |
| 2001 | Mike Naumann** | Baseball | 1st | P |
| 2001 | Vanessa Pruzinsky***# | Women's At-Large (Soccer) | 1st | D |
| 2001 | Vanessa Pruzinsky***# | Women's Soccer | 1st | D |
| 2001 | Steve Ratay** | Men's At-Large (Golf) | 3rd | |
| 2001 | Ruth Riley**#! | Women's Basketball | 1st | C |
| 2001 | Jennifer Sharron | Softball | 1st | P |
| 2001 | Brian Stavisky** | Baseball | 3rd | OF |
| 2001 | Monica Gonzalez | Women's Soccer | 3rd | D |
| 2002 | Andrew Bushey | Baseball | 2nd | IF |
| 2002 | Jarrah Myers***# | Softball | 1st | C |
| 2002 | Steve Ratay** | Men's At-Large (Golf) | 2nd | |
| 2002 | Ryan Shay | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2002 | Brian Stavisky** | Baseball | 3rd | OF |
| 2002 | Luke Watson** | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2002 | John Crowther | Football | 2nd | OL |
| 2003 | J.P. Gagne | Baseball | 3rd | P |
| 2003 | Steve Sollmann** | Baseball | 2nd | IF |
| 2003 | Luke Watson** | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2003 | Erika Bohn*** | Women's Soccer | 2nd | G |
| 2003 | Mary Boland | Women's Soccer | 2nd | F |
| 2003 | Vanessa Pruzinsky***# | Women's Soccer | 1st | D |
| 2004 | Lauren King | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2004 | Annie Schefter** | Women's Soccer | 1st | M |
| 2004 | Todd Mobley** | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2004 | Steve Sollmann** | Baseball | 1st | IF |
| 2004 | Erika Bohn*** | Women's Soccer | 1st | G |
| 2005 | Kelli Barton | Women's At-Large (Swimming) | 2nd | |
| 2005 | Todd Mobley** | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2005 | Stacey Cowan** | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 3rd | |
| 2005 | Sean O'Donnell** | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 3rd | |
| 2005 | Annie Schefter** | Women's Soccer | 1st | M |
| 2005 | Erika Bohn*** | Women's Soccer | 1st | G |
| 2005 | Lauren Brewster | Volleyball | 2nd | MB |
| 2005 | John Stephens | Men's Soccer | 2nd | M |
| 2006 | Stephanie Brown** | Softball | 2nd | OF |
| 2006 | Thomas Chamney** | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 3rd | |
| 2006 | Stacey Cowan** | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2006 | Megan Duffy | Women's Basketball | 1st | G |
| 2006 | Greg Lopez | Baseball | 3rd | IF |
| 2006 | Stephanie Madia | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2006 | Tim Moore | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 3rd | |
| 2006 | Meghan Murphy | Women's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 3rd | M |
| 2006 | Sean O'Donnell** | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2006 | Chris Quinn | Men's Basketball | 1st | G |
| 2006 | Ashley Jones** | Women's Soccer | 1st | D |
| 2006 | John Carlson** | Football | 1st | TE |
| 2007 | Ted Brown | Men's At-Large (Swimming) | 3rd | |
| 2007 | Mary Carpenter | Women's At-Large (Lacrosse) | 3rd | M |
| 2007 | Stephanie Brown** | Softball | 2nd | OF |
| 2007 | Thomas Chamney** | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2007 | Maryann Erigha | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2007 | Brett Lilley** | Baseball | 1st | IF |
| 2007 | Sunni Olding | Women's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2007 | Todd Ptacek | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2007 | Brittany Bock** | Women's Soccer | 3rd | F/M |
| 2007 | John Carlson** | Football | 2nd | TE |
| 2007 | Ashley Jones** | Women's Soccer | 1st | M |
| 2007 | Trevor Laws | Football | 2nd | DL |
| 2007 | Ryan Miller | Men's Soccer | 2nd | M |
| 2008 | Brett Lilley** | Baseball | 1st | IF |
| 2008 | Adrienne Nott | Women's At-Large (Fencing) | 3rd | |
| 2008 | Jordan Pearce** | Men's At-Large (Hockey) | 2nd | G |
| 2008 | Mike Anello | Football | 2nd | DB |
| 2008 | Matt Belser | Men's Soccer | 1st | D |
| 2008 | Brittany Bock** | Women's Soccer | 1st | F/M |
| 2008 | Elise Weber | Women's Soccer | 2nd | D |
| 2009 | Lauren Buck | Women's At-Large (Rowing) | 3rd | |
| 2009 | Erik Condra | Men's At-Large (Hockey) | 2nd | F |
| 2009 | Jordan Pearce** | Men's At-Large (Hockey) | 1st | G |
| 2009 | Patrick Smyth | Men's Cross Country/Track & Field | 1st |
|
| 2010 | Mike Anello** | Football | 2nd | CB |
| 2010 | Tim Abromaitis | Men's Basketball | 1st | F |
| 2010 | Cosmina Ciobanu | Women's At-Large (Tennis) | 2nd | |
| 2010 | Lauren Fowlkes** | Women's Soccer | 2nd | F |
| 2010 | Christine Lux | Softball | 2nd | 1B |
| 2010 | Michael Thomas | Men's Soccer | 3rd | M |
| 2010 | Lauren Fowlkes** | Women's Soccer | 1st | D |
| 2010 | David Ruffer | Football | 1st | PK |
| ** - Two-time Academic All-American |
| *** - Three-time Academic All-American |
| + - Academic All-America Hall of Fame inductee |
| # - Academic All-America Team Member Of The Year |
| ! - Academic All-American Of The Year |
